Rensselaer's Mico De Los Santos was named the Section II Class D Most Valuable Player in 2009. A wide receiver/running back combination, De Los Santos was also one of the most ferocious tacklers out of the defensive backfield.

MVP - Mico De Los Santos, Rensselaer

Offensive Player of the Year - Caleb Meroski, Lake George
Defensive Player of the Year - Nate Butler, Rensselaer
Coach of the Year - Joel Preston, Rensselaer

First team
Offense

QB - Derrick Pitts, Bishop Gibbons
RB - Tyler Pruiksma, Greenwich
Jashem Hamilton, Rensselear
Justin White, Fort Edward
WR - Kyle McKeighan, Salem
Ryan McFee, Greenwich
TE - Rob Redman, Bishop Gibbons
OL - Ben Barbour, Greenwich
Jack Clark, Lake George
Todd DeLuke, Rensselaer
Cory Christian, Whitehall
Nick Abare, Fort Edward
PK - Tim Pompa, Saratoga Central Catholic
KR - Brendan Frye, Warrensburg

Defense

DL - Jason Brown, Rensselaer
Josh Fleming, Bishop Gibbons
Chad Niles, Greenwich
Jack Keller, Saratoga Central Catholic
LB - David Northshield, Salem
Dave Mulcahy, Saratoga Central Catholic
Colby Stout, Greenwich
Phil Sayers, Rensselaer
DB - Connor Dougherty, Bishop Gibbons
Ryan Maxwell, Bishop Gibbons
Dylan Anderson, Saratoga Central Catholic
P - Pat Wilson, Salem

Honorable mention

Bishop Gibbons - Victor Villanueva, Matt Butrym
Fort Edward - Steve Chapman, Mark Yagy, Ben Sawyer, Jonah Taylor
Greenwich - Tony Giroux, Neil Fryer, Jordan James, Collin McCormick, Alex Stuart, Mike Orminski
Lake George - Josh Borgh, Matt McGowan, Robert Adsit, Kris Koscz
Rensselaer - Marquee James, Keith McElroy, Paul Dominy, Tyler Bishop
Salem - Jacob Dyker, Austin Eastman
Saratoga Central Catholic - Joe Durand, Dale Long, Nick Valenze
Warrensburg - Mike Perrone, Jason Power
Whitehall - Chris Therrian, Mike Kline, Will Stafford